Porn News

Attorney Lawrence Walters Comments on Supreme Court’s Review of Law Banning Violent Video Games

from – The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday agreed to review a California law banning the sale of violent video games to minors.

California civil code 1746.1 reads “A person may not sell or rent a video game that has been labeled as a violent video game to a minor.”

The Supreme Court will review Schwarzenegger v. Video Software Dealers, which appeals the overturning of the statute in lower courts, when it reconvenes in October.

The decision to review the case comes a week after its 8-1 U.S. v. Stevens ruling, in which the Court struck down a law banning the distribution of dogfighting videos.

“It’s a bit of a surprising decision by the Supreme Court to hear the argument in the case,” Lawrence G. Walters, managing partner of the Walters Law Group, told the E-Commerce Times.

“It seems like the Stevens decision answers the question. It would be unconstitutional under Stevens. Violence has never been a basis to restrict speech in the United States, and this would be the first time that any restriction on violent speech would be upheld.”

The Stevens case was a more difficult case to decide, according to Walters, though it still didn’t meet the limits to ban speech.

“Here we’re talking about cartoon avatars and CGI representations of violence,” he said. “The arguments are not nearly as strong as in the Schwarzenegger case. In light of Stevens, it would be very difficult for the state of California to prevail.”

The video game case raises the question of whether the state of California should be in the business of deciding what games are appropriate for children to play, Walters said. “Do they not trust parents? Do they believe [violence in video games] is a sin?”

It’s unusual that the Supreme Court would hear the case because all of the courts below it struck down the California law, Walters noted. It’s likely the Court will find the law unconstitutional, he predicted, because “the government has never been able to establish any kind of link [between] psychological harm to children and playing violent games.”

The state of California is trying to draw a link between children playing violent video games and engaging in violent behavior, said Stephen Smith, a partner at Greenberg Glusker, but “there is no competent scientific consensus that playing violent video games causes this behavior at all.”

If the Supreme Court were to uphold the California law, it would throw into question violence in other forms of media, Smith told the E-Commerce Times.

“If this was upheld, I don’t see how you draw the line between this and books. I personally think they’re not going to do it,” he said. “That would be a sea change in the entire entertainment industry, and I would be amazed if the Supreme Court is going to do that.”


Related Posts

Against All Odds: The Trials, Tribulations & Triumphs of CJ Miles

They called it a competition, but CJ Miles didn’t see it that way.

Kamasutra Releases Fall/Halloween Seasonal Candles

MOORPARK, Calif. — Kamasutra has released its seasonal collection of Naughty Notes Fall massage candles. The Halloween-inspired display houses 16 hand-poured candles, each featuring one of four Naughty Notes messages with a pumpkin spice-inspired fragrance. “Fall is a time for…

Grand Vision: Vanna Bardot Discusses ‘Influence’ Vixen Media Group Showcase

As reigning XBIZ Female Performer of the Year, Vanna Bardot has fully capitalized on her skyward momentum since earning her crown this past January, bringing her highly professional rep and glamcore bona fides to bear on hitting newly triumphant strides…

Triple Win: When the Pleasure Industry Gets Charitable, Everybody Benefits

The pleasure industry has always been about helping people to feel good, and today innovators are doing so in even more far-reaching ways. There is a constant stream of new products released, each designed to encourage users to feel better…

Blake Blossom, Skye Blue Headline ‘Lesbian Superstars 3’

Blake Blossom and Skye Blue headline "Lesbian Superstars 3," the newest chapter of the acclaimed series from Lesbian X.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.