Porn News

Federal judge rejects adult store’s challenge to Mo. county ordinance

From A recent federal court decision highlights a recurring — and unsettled — First Amendment question: Do all adult businesses cause the same harmful secondary effects?

The case involves a Jackson County, Mo., ordinance that regulates adult businesses. Enlightened Reading Inc., which does business as Erotic City, challenged the ordinance in federal court. Erotic City is a retail store in Jackson County that sells various novelties and lingerie, including some sexually explicit material.

According to Enlightened Reading, the county’s ordinance is unconstitutional as applied to retail stores that only sell and rent material. County officials, the company contended, failed to take into account the difference between an establishment like Erotic City that offers only “off-site” adult entertainment — i.e., where customers enter, purchase a product and leave — and a business that offers “on-site” entertainment — i.e., where customers view nude dancing or other adult performances and remain on the premises for a longer period.

Enlightened Reading said that when the county adopted the ordinance, it relied on secondary-effects studies done in other jurisdictions that focused on on-site adult businesses. The company attempted to rely on a decision from the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Encore Videos v. City of San Antonio (2003), which said there was a distinction between on-site and off-site businesses. The rationale was that customers of off-site businesses do not linger on the premises long enough to cause harmful secondary effects.

Unfortunately for Erotic City, federal district courts in Missouri must follow the law of the 8th Circuit, not the 5th Circuit. Chief Judge Fernando J. Gaitan [pictured] of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri noted in his March 24 opinion in Enlightened Reading v. Jackson County that 5th Circuit case law is at odds with 8th Circuit law.

“While the Encore Videos court (the 5th Circuit) was free to adopt its own interpretation regarding this distinction, this Court must follow the binding authority in this circuit,” Gaitan wrote. He noted that that the 8th Circuit had rejected the distinction between on-site and off-site adult businesses in ILQ Investments v. City of Rochester (1994).

Gaitan also wrote that the Jackson County ordinance was constitutional because the county did rely on secondary-effects studies and judicial opinions from other jurisdictions that dealt with off-site adult businesses.

Gaitan then went on to find that “the ordinance does not seek to suppress speech or expression, directly or indirectly” and that the “county makes clear that it does not intend to suppress speech or expression, but rather seeks to combat harmful effects from such businesses.”

Whether this decision will be appealed remains to be seen, but the case aptly illustrates a division in the federal circuit courts on an important issue — often an effective predictor for possible Supreme Court review.


Related Posts

Kamasutra Releases Fall/Halloween Seasonal Candles

MOORPARK, Calif. — Kamasutra has released its seasonal collection of Naughty Notes Fall massage candles. The Halloween-inspired display houses 16 hand-poured candles, each featuring one of four Naughty Notes messages with a pumpkin spice-inspired fragrance. “Fall is a time for…

Grand Vision: Vanna Bardot Discusses ‘Influence’ Vixen Media Group Showcase

As reigning XBIZ Female Performer of the Year, Vanna Bardot has fully capitalized on her skyward momentum since earning her crown this past January, bringing her highly professional rep and glamcore bona fides to bear on hitting newly triumphant strides…

Triple Win: When the Pleasure Industry Gets Charitable, Everybody Benefits

The pleasure industry has always been about helping people to feel good, and today innovators are doing so in even more far-reaching ways. There is a constant stream of new products released, each designed to encourage users to feel better…

Blake Blossom, Skye Blue Headline ‘Lesbian Superstars 3’

Blake Blossom and Skye Blue headline "Lesbian Superstars 3," the newest chapter of the acclaimed series from Lesbian X.

Will Ranscombe of Love Not War to Speak at RSVC

LONDON — Will Ranscombe, CEO of British pleasure brand Love Not War, will speak at the Reimagine Sexuality Virtual Conference this weekend. Taking place Oct. 1, Ranscombe's presentation, titled "Pleasure Should Not Cost The Earth: Sustainability in the SexTech Industry,"…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.