Porn News

Judge: “Bump messages” are not republication

[]- So-called “bump messages” — new comments made to older messages in order to move them back up to prominent positions on a Web site and keep a conversation alive — do not count as republication in the libel context, a New York judge wrote in an opinion last week.

“One of the unique characteristics of the Internet is that it allows for the ‘dissemination of information and ideas’ on a global scale,” wrote Supreme Court Justice Herman Cahn [pictured]. (The Supreme Court is the trial-level court in New York.) Considering bump messages to be a type of republication, he said, “would have a ‘serious inhibitory effect’ on this form of communication.”

Cahn said bump messages appropriately fall under the single-publication rule governing other periodicals in New York: No matter how widely circulated a magazine or newspaper may be, if it prints a defamatory statement in one issue it can only be held liable for one act of publication.

The ruling came in a dispute that arose out of an underlying case in which Admission Consultants Inc., a firm focused on helping prospective college and graduate students with their applications, claimed it was the subject of defamatory remarks in the “B-Schools” forum on Business Week’s Web site.

A judge last year ordered McGraw Hill Publishing Co., Business Week’s publisher, to identify 12 users accused of making the offending statements. Two of the users, “globalup” and “diverdavis,” had Google e-mail accounts; Admission Consultants said the e-mail addresses were insufficiently identifying, and it pursued Google for more information on those users.

According to Cahn’s opinion, the two users posted messages over a period of several months on the thread, “Do not use” Diverdavis reportedly once posted to the thread, “these guys sound like complete crooks.” Globalup agreed with other commenters that the company was not legitimate and also posted six of the so-called bump messages.

Cahn said those statements were a matter of opinion and, as such, were not libelous. Based on that, he denied Admission Consultants’ request that Google give up identifying information on the users.


Related Posts

Conservative Taxpayers Group Criticizes KOSA’s Overreach

WASHINGTON — Conservative newspaper The Washington Times published Tuesday an opinion piece by the executive director of the Taxpayers Protection Alliance criticizing KOSA on constitutional grounds.KOSA, wrote TPA’s Patrick Hedger, “has been circulating for years, and the sponsors of the legislation…

Remy LaCroix Returns in LucidFlix’s ‘Ultimacy III – The Author’

2013 AVN Best New Starlet Remy LaCroix makes her first comeback appearance in "The Author," the latest scene of actor/director Seth Gamble's VPOV (virtual point-of-view) production "Ultimacy III."

NightMoves Announces Nominees, Details for 32nd Annual Awards

The 32nd Annual NightMoves Awards Show Weekend is scheduled for October 10-13, 2024 in Tampa Bay, Florida, and voting is now open for the array of nominated talent, crew, nightclubs and more.

More Conservative Organizations Distance Themselves From Anti-Porn Project 2025

WASHINGTON — A growing list of conservative groups which had formerly endorsed Project 2025 — which calls for the total criminalization of adult content production and distribution — have reportedly distanced themselves from the self-described "presidential transition" blueprint, following Donald…

Wendy Raine Signs With Nexxxt Level Talent

Jul 19, 2024 4:25 PM PDTLAS VEGAS — Wendy Raine has signed with Nexxxt Level Talent for representation. “This has been the best year of my career for so many reasons," said Raine. "It has been a year of discovery, passion, and…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.