Porn News

Nitke Loses Gonzales Challenge

New York- A three-judge panel this week shot down a challenge to a law barring the transmission of a wide variety of speech about alterative sexual expression because of the perceived threat such materials pose to minors.

In deciding the case, Nitke v Gonzales, formerly Nitke v Ashcroft, the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York upheld the prevailing broad definition of obscenity and noted that the Communications Decency Act of 1996 “prohibits any transmission of obscenity by means of the internet” unless age verification requirements or “good faith” efforts to prevent minors from viewing the material are undertaken.

The plaintiff, Barbara Nitke, is an artist who photographs various sexual activities. Her suit challenged the Act as overly broad and unconstitutional, Court papers state. She also holds that the ban has deterred her from exercising her free speech rights.

Joining Nitke in challenging the law was the National Coalition for Sexual Freedom (NCSF), which bills itself as an “organization committed to creating a political, legal and social environment in the United States that advances equal rights of consenting adults who practice forms of alternative sexual expression,” such as bondage, swinging and polyamory.

Following Monday’s decision, NCSF attorney John Wirenius said, “artists and citizens who are sexual minorities are disproportionately censored by the government’s ability to pick its own forum and standard for obscenity cases.”

In upholding the obscenity standards, the Court said the plaintiffs failed to provide “sufficient evidence to enable us to determine, for the United States as a whole, the extent to which standards vary from community to community.”

“Indeed,” the judges wrote, “the plaintiffs’ expert witness testified that he was unable to determine the standards for obscenity in any given region.”

Obscenity is famously ill-defined. According to court papers, “contemporary community standards,” as set forth in a 1973 ruling, remains the prevailing definition.

238 Views

Related Posts

2026 AVN Show Set to Return to Virgin Hotels Las Vegas in January

AVN Media Network is pleased to announce the AVN Show— the largest adult entertainment expo in the world—will return January 21-24, 2026, at Virgin Hotels Las Vegas.

Metro Announces Plans for New Output in Coming Months

30 Views

Sweetheart Drops ‘Lesbian Adventures: Strap-On Specialists 19’

Adult A-listers Ryan Keely and Nicole Doshi headline "Lesbian Adventures: Strap-On Specialists 19," from Mile High Media’s all-girl studio Sweetheart Video.

Nominees Announced for 7th Annual Pornhub Awards

Pornhub on Thursday announced the nominees for the 7th annual Pornhub Awards, taking place May 8 in Los Angeles.

Girlfriends Releases ‘Women Seeking Women 199’

All-girl studio Girlfriends Films has released the 199th volume of its flagship series "Women Seeking Women" via video-on-demand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *