Porn News

USSupreme Court Hears Arguments in Michael Williams Free Speech Kiddie Porn Case

WASHINGTON – Several U.S. Supreme Court justices expressed doubt on Tuesday that a law barring child pornography could be applied to popular award-winning movies like “Lolita,” “Traffic,” American Beauty” and “Titanic.”

The justices appeared to support the pandering provision of a 2003 federal law that makes it a crime to promote, distribute or solicit material in a way intended to cause others to believe it contains child pornography.

They were hearing arguments in a case brought by the Bush administration urging them to uphold the law, after a U.S. appeals court struck down that provision on the grounds the government cannot suppress lawful free speech.

Bush administration lawyer Paul Clement argued that the law does not illegally infringe on free-speech or other rights guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.

He said the law does not inhibit legitimate creative expression, and drew a distinction between mainstream movies and illegal child pornography.

“If you’re taking a movie like ‘Traffic’ or ‘American Beauty’, which is not child pornography, and you’re simply truthfully promoting it, you have nothing to worry about with this statute,” Clement told the justices.

“Traffic” has a scene with the high-school daughter of the nation’s drug czar appearing to have sex with a drug dealer; “Lolita” portrayed a middle-aged man’s obsession with a young girl; “Titanic” depicted a love affair by a young couple on a doomed ship; and “American Beauty” involved a 42-year-old man’s attraction to his daughter’s best friend.

Chief Justice John Roberts asked the attorney who is challenging the law about the government’s distinction between legitimate films and illegal child pornography.

Lawyer Richard Diaz is representing a Florida man, Michael Williams, who was arrested in 2004 after he traded messages in an Internet chat room with an undercover federal agent posing as a woman.

Williams offered to trade photos of children with the agent and then posted seven images of minors in sexually explicit conduct. At issue before the Supreme Court is his conviction for promoting child pornography.

“Your client … didn’t produce Lolita,” Roberts said to Diaz. Roberts expressed concern that Williams could argue the law might be applied too broadly in hypothetical cases like “Lolita.”

Justice Stephen Breyer cited the movies “American Beauty” and “Traffic” and noted Clement’s position. “I don’t see under his interpretation how anyone could conceivably be prosecuted,” Breyer said.

Diaz argued the law punished “thought, beliefs, expressions and opinions.” He said someone could be convicted if they cited one of the films like Lolita and said it contained “hot graphic teen sex.”

Justice David Souter seemed skeptical of that argument. “Most 17-year-olds are, in fact, going to realize the real thing is not going on in, you know, the Lolita movie,” he said.

The Supreme Court in 2002 struck down an earlier version of the law that included computer-generated images that appeared to depict minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct.

Congress then adopted new legislation in 2003, which President George W. Bush signed into law, in an effort to comply with the Supreme Court’s ruling.

A ruling on the current case is expected by the end of June.

219 Views

Related Posts

Ray Ray’s Content Now Available on DVD From Pulse Distribution

Adult star Ray Ray has made her content available on DVD, after securing a deal with adult distributor Pulse Distribution.

SayUncle Names Giovanni as February’s ‘AllStar’

Feb 11, 2025 5:06 PM PSTLOS ANGELES — SayUncle Network has named Giovanni as its February AllStar, spotlighting him with Benji Jagger in "Giovanni’s Valentine Dick Down Debut." Jagger plays "a reserved young man looking to boost his confidence before…

Francesca Le, Mark Wood Debut ‘The LeWood Anal Hazing Crew 9’

Married AVN Hall-Of-Fame members Francesca Le and Mark Wood have released the fetish-themed "The LeWood Anal Hazing Crew #9," available now on VOD and DVD from Evil Angel.

Mochi Mona Stars in Latest from TadpoleXStudio

Feb 10, 2025 5:44 PM PSTLOS ANGELES — Mochi Mona stars in the latest scene for TadpoleXStudio, with Wolf Dom and site honcho Tad Pole. "The pair meet up with the brazen bespectacled brunette slut in a hotel room where…

Flirt4Free’s ‘Be My Valentine’ Cam Contest Returns

Flirt4Free has announced the return of the "Be My Valentine" celebration.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.