Porn News

Tennessee Rep. Joe Carr says HB 3081 which raises taxes on strippers, escorts, pornography, sex toys, is about saving marriages

Follow AdultFYI at twitter@adultfyi1; Follow Gene Ross at twitter@GeneRoss3

Nashville- from www.newschannel5.com – A state lawmaker from Rutherford County has proposed a tax that could increase state revenue by $55 million. Representative Joe Carr of Lascassas said taxing adult businesses, and the products they sell, is a way to help all Tennesseans.

“If we can’t outlaw it, and the Supreme Court says we cannot, then what we’ll do is put a 25% tax on adult material, hard core pornography,” Representative Carr said.

Carr claims his proposal is about more than just money. He said his real concern is about saving marriages. He said that Tennessee has one of the highest divorce rates and he’s hoping his proposal will change that.

According to the bill he filed, the adult entertainment industry generates nearly $222 million a year in Tennessee.

A 25 % sales tax would be applied to adult movies, books or admission to any adult entertainment venue. It would also apply to escort services and cabarets.

“Any types of items where you’re required to be 18 years of age, or older to either go into those establishments, or buy those materials,” according to Carr.

Carr has proposed to use the money collected from the adult entertainment tax to lower, or eliminate, the sales tax on food.

Constitutional experts think the proposed bill most likely violates the First Amendment.

“To tax something based on its First Amendment content would clearly be unconstitutional in my view,” said attorney David Raybin.

According to Raybin states have the legal right to impose so-called sin taxes on liquor and tobacco products.

“Those are commercial products and do not have any First Amendment aspects to it. Pornography, although it may be offensive to some people is protected under the first amendment,” Raybin explained.

He said if the proposed bill became law, it would be immediately challenged in court.

Representative Carr does not feel his proposed bill violates the First Amendment. In fact, he believes the bill will receive bi-partisan support in the legislature.

“Liberal democrats are always looking for places to increase revenue. Conservative republicans are always looking for things that can support family values,” Carr explained.

Carr said the bill still has to be revised before it makes its way through the legislative process.

from www.nashvillescene.com -Honest to god, If it wasn’t bad enough having to think of Jim Gotto and Jack Johnson writing legislation pertaining to child pubes, here come Joe Carr and perpetual asshat Stacey Campfield writing legislation that contains the actual phrase, “A female breast below a point immediately above the top of the areola.”

You may be wondering how all this legislation pertaining to genitals and breasts and what they do and to whom is going to help solve our state’s problems — and I have to tell you, I don’t know.

Joe Carr says that this bill, HB 3081, which raises taxes on strippers, escorts, pornography and sex toys, is about saving marriages. Apparently Rep. Carr has no idea that pornography is available for free on the internet, so if one’s spouse has a penchant for it, the Hustler store being too expensive isn’t going to dissuade him or her.

Also, if Carr doesn’t think that a properly placed vibrator has saved a marriage or two in its day, it can only be because he hasn’t tried it.

But let’s dwell on Campfield a second. Over at his blog, he says, “This will put one simple question out there to legislators. Why would you vote for cheap porn, escorts and strippers and against lowering the tax on food?”

Yes, as always, Campfield is keeping those bitchez in line. Wherever a woman might be doing something with her body that Stacey Campfield doesn’t approve of, you can count on him trying to pass legislation to make her life more difficult.

We still have an unemployment rate of 9 percent in this state, with some places almost twice that, and Campfield wants to make it more difficult for these women to do their jobs? Nice.

But here’s the other claim he makes: “The fiscal study says the tax swap will generate $55 million in Tennessee in the first year alone (and it looks pretty stable after that) and the income generated would be dedicated to lowering the tax on food by up to triple (or even possibly more) the amount the governor has proposed in the next year. ” Wow. Really? Fifty-five million dollars?

Let’s take a look at that fiscal note.

—Based on data obtained from the U.S. Census Bureau, the population in Tennessee for 2011 was estimated to be 6,346,105; the population for the U.S. is currently estimated to be 312,602,730.
—Tennessee makes up 2.03 percent of the national population (6,346,105 / 312,602,730).
—Tennessee accounts for 2.03 percent (or $267,960,000) of the adult entertainment industry’s total gross revenue ($13.2 billion x 2.03%).

That’s just over $42 a person a year we’re spending on porn, strippers, escorts, and sex toys. Each and every one of us. Even the babies. We are a bunch of perverts.

Except… the numbers bandied about for how much money the porn industry makes are notoriously unreliable. Forbes looked at this back in 2001 — which, yes, is a long time ago, but also a long time ago before the explosion of amateur porn available for free on the Internet. Back then, they were saying, “For the $10 billion figure to be accurate, you have to add in adult video networks and pay-per-view movies on cable and satellite, Web sites, in-room hotel movies, phone sex, sex toys and magazines — and still you can’t get there.” Ten billion is what folks were claiming back in 2001. I guess $13 billion is what folks are claiming now.

But it’s worth it to look at Forbes’ argument. At the time there was simply no way for porn to be making that much money. They put the number at $4 billion or less, a decade ago. And in the ensuing decade, we’ve seen the rise of amateur porn on the internet, the continuing struggles of Playboy, and the tendency of for-sale porn to cater to smaller and more specialized niches. In other words, it seems unlikely to me that the Forbes numbers are very far off where we are now. Adult entertainment revenues certainly haven’t tripled since 2001. We all lost our jobs, our houses, and our savings.

So, yes, even if we take the high number Forbes gives ($3.9 billion), and we double it in spite of all the evidence pointing to the unlikelihood of there being that kind of growth, that’s still just $7.8 billion, our share of which, after running the little adjustment noted in the fiscal note, is $138,553,000. That’s $21.83 a person (even the babies) per year. Under this legislation, we’d pay $5.46 in taxes on that, which is $34,638,000 in tax revenue, not $55 million. And that’s assuming a best case scenario — that the Forbes numbers have somehow, magically, doubled.

If the Forbes numbers have held steady, we only account for $79 million in adult entertainment revenue. Making the adjustment noted in the fiscal note, that would give us state tax revenue of $17,319,000, and $17 million is a far cry from $55 million.

I don’t suppose $17 million is anything to sneeze at, and I know, when you’re out of ideas for helping people, there’s nothing like a little scapegoating. But before we go vilifying people’s jobs and blaming them for the ruination of Tennessee’s marriages, we ought to at least have our numbers right.

244 Views

Related Posts

MYLF Drops 6 New Scenes

Apr 12, 2024 4:26 PM PDTMIAMI — MYLF has released six new scenes this week starring Suki Sin, Christie Stevens, Katie Morgan, and others. First, in Mom Swap's “Welcome to the Frat Swap," stepmoms Elana Bunnz and Cassie Lenoir visit their stepsons…

Penthouse Opens Voting for the 2024 ‘Pet of the Year’ Playoffs

Penthouse is inviting the public to vote for their favorite Penthouse Pet to be awarded Pet of the Year 2024.

Tahlia Paris Named Penthouse Pet of the Year 2023

Penthouse Reveals a Symphony for the Eyes - Announces DJ, Model, and Influencer Tahlia Paris as 2023’s Pet of the Year

Tonga Expands Dreamtoys Startroopers Collection

AXEL, The Netherlands — Tonga has added six more anal stimulation toys to its space-themed Dreamtoys Startroopers collection. The new anal products include three-piece plug kit Milky Way, beaded vibrator Hubble, grooved plug Triton, vibrating plug Pluto, rotating and vibrating plug…

Brazzers Set to Unveil Jewelz Blu’s First Anal Scene

Brazzers will release 'Obsessive Anal Thoughts," Jewelz Blu’s anal debut, on Friday.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.